Introducing Our New 12-Point Publisher Checklist

Why Publisher Quality Matters

A successful link-building strategy hinges on one crucial factor: the quality of the websites you earn links from. Low-quality or spammy sites can undermine your search engine optimization (SEO) efforts, while high-quality publishers can significantly boost your visibility and authority.

Over the years, many SEO professionals and clients have asked: “How can I quickly identify a credible publisher for link building?” To address this, we developed a 12-Point Publisher Checklist—a framework that outlines the essential criteria for evaluating and selecting reputable publishers. In this post, we’ll walk you through these 12 points to help you improve the quality of your own link-building campaigns.

Why We Created the 12-Point Checklist 

We’ve always been dedicated to delivering the best possible results for our clients. But one recurring question kept coming up: “How do I know if this publisher is good?” Clients wanted a clear, consistent way to asses publishers and make sure they are getting real value from their link-building efforts. 

After years of experience and thousands of successful placements, we decided to formalize our process. The result is our 12-Point Publisher Checklist, which covers everything from verifying publisher legitimacy to making sure the content is high-quality and links stay up long-term. 

Our 12-Point Publisher Checklist

Below is a snapshot of the criteria we use to ensure each publisher is credible, relevant, and beneficial for long-term SEO success. Use these guidelines to build your own checklist or to evaluate any potential publishing partner.

1. Verified Business, News, or Blog Website
   A legitimate website will typically have a clear mission, consistent branding, and genuine content. Look for a transparent “About Us” page, a cohesive layout, and indicators that the site is actively maintained.
2. Authentic Contact Information
   A credible publisher will list real contact details. This demonstrates accountability and fosters trust. Anonymous or hard-to-reach site owners can be a red flag.
3. No “Write for Us” Pages or Paid Link Advertisements
   Websites that openly advertise link sales or guest posts often attract spammy or low-quality contributions. Search engines may devalue links from these sources, making them risky for your SEO.
4. Do-Follow Links Only
   Do-follow links pass authority (or “link juice”) to your site. Ensure that any agreement you make includes do-follow links rather than no-follow or sponsored attributes.
5. No Mentions of Sponsored or Paid Content
   The most effective links appear naturally within the content. Overtly labeling links as “sponsored” or “paid” can reduce their SEO value and may signal search engines that the link is promotional.
6. Niche-Relevant, SEO-Optimized Content
   Relevance is key to effective link building. Make sure the publisher’s content relates to your industry or topic and follows on-page SEO best practices (proper headers, keyword usage, etc.).
7. Minimum Domain Rating (DR) & Domain Authority (DA) of 20
   Domain metrics like DR (Ahrefs) and DA (Moz) are common ways to gauge a site’s overall authority. While these metrics aren’t the only factor to consider, ensuring a baseline of at least 20 can help you avoid very low-authority sites.
8. Minimum Ahrefs Traffic of 500
   A publisher should have tangible monthly traffic—at least 500 visitors—so your link stands a better chance of being seen and clicked.
9. Stable Traffic Patterns
   Check traffic history for sudden drops or long-term declines of over 50%. A massive, unexplained decline might indicate a penalty or other issues that could harm your link’s value.
10. Verified Ownership (No Brokers)
    Work directly with recognized site owners to avoid hidden fees, spammy networks, or other intermediaries that could compromise quality and transparency.
11. Guaranteed 12-Month Placement
    High-quality publishers will commit to keeping your link live for a reasonable period. Aim for at least 12 months to ensure your content has time to gain traction in search results.
12. No Orphaned Posts
    Each published article should be internally linked to relevant pages within the site, which helps both users and search engines discover and index your content.

Seeing the 12-Point Checklist in Action 

We’ve built everything we know about finding quality publishers right into our platform. Now, every publisher we recommend for your link-building projects will meet the standards of this checklist—unless you request something specific that falls outside of these criteria. 

Here’s how clients can use this: 

1. Create a Project

You can create a project on our platform, and we’ll suggest publishers that align with your goals. You’ll have full control to review them and choose the ones you want to purchase. Rest assured, every publisher we suggest meets our 12-point quality checklist, so you know you’re getting links from trusted, high-quality sites. 

2. Done-For-You (DFY) Product

If you’d prefer a more hands-off approach, our Done-For-You product might be perfect for you. With DFY, you pay a set price, and we take care of everything—from selecting the best publishers to placing the orders. No need to review publishers yourself since we can handle that for you, strictly following our 12-point checklist to guarantee quality placements. 

Our system makes it simple: every link you get through us meets these quality standards. You can choose publishers yourself or let us do it for you—whatever works best for your needs. 

Key Benefits of a Rigorous Vetting Process

• Long-Term SEO Value: High-quality links stand the test of time and are less likely to be devalued by search engines.
• Better Brand Authority: Associating your brand with credible publishers can improve brand perception and recognition.
• Reduced Penalty Risks: Search engines routinely penalize sites associated with link schemes. A stringent checklist helps avoid that.
• Improved ROI: When you focus on link quality rather than sheer quantity, your investments in SEO tend to yield more sustainable, higher-impact returns.

Final Thoughts

Link building can be a powerful tool in your SEO strategy—but only if done responsibly. By focusing on the 12-Point Publisher Checklist, you ensure each placement is credible, relevant, and offers long-lasting value. Whether you choose to build links manually or work with professional services, applying these guidelines will help you avoid penalties, strengthen your site’s authority, and bolster your search rankings over the long haul.

If you’re ready to fine-tune your link-building efforts, consider adopting these criteria into your workflow. By holding every publisher to the same high standards, you’ll set yourself up for consistent, high-quality SEO results.

👉 Login to Your Account or Speak to someone on our team.